Core Values-Based Appreciative Questions
(The first four questions are based on the Core Values of the Presbytery of Milwaukee that were adopted by the Presbytery in May 2011)
1. Leadership: Calling, Equipping, and sustaining leaders who will serve the people with energy, intelligence, imagination, and love
Leadership in the church can mean many things, from sharing an amazing vision for the future to running a good committee meeting to giving an inspirational sermon to being a wise steward of resources.
In your experience, in this Presbytery or elsewhere, what would you point to as an example of gifted leadership? What made it so remarkable? Who was this person or group and what was this person or group doing? How did people respond? What, if anything, was accomplished? How do you think this person (or these people) learned to do what they were doing? What did you learn? What role did God play in this person’s or group’s leadership?
What leadership development experiences have you had, through the Presbytery or elsewhere, that significantly improved your leadership capacity?
2. Congregations: Nurturing healthy congregations and fostering connections among congregations to share God’s love in the world and live the gospel of Jesus Christ
Some congregations seem to always be healthy while others seem to struggle.
Talk about a healthy congregation that you have known. What did it look like? How did it embody Jesus Christ? How did its members behave toward each other? Toward strangers? Toward other congregations? From your perspective, what contributed to its health? What made it feel so good? What did you learn as a result of being touched by it in some way? Where was God at work in this congregation?
Talk about a less than healthy congregation that you have known. What were the challenges that it faced? How did its members behave? What did you learn from it? Where was God at work in this congregation?
3. Trust: Entrusting ourselves to one another so that we reflect who God calls us to be
Trust, whether in the church, the home, or the workplace, is in some ways an unexpected gift and in some ways the product of hard work and persistence.
Describe a person or group whom you have come to trust. What brought you together? How did you nurture your trust for each other? What hurdles did you have to overcome in order to trust each other? What, if anything, happened as a result of your trust for each other? What lessons did you learn as you came to trust each other? What happened when you disagreed with this person or group? Where did you see God in this relationship?
4. Risk: Creating an atmosphere that encourages risk-taking for the sake of the Gospel in this time and place
Taking a risk is always difficult, even when it’s for the sake of the Gospel, because we never know what might have to change, either within ourselves or in our relationships with others.
Talk about a time in your life, in your current congregation or elsewhere, when you’ve taken a risk. What did you do? How did it feel? Who else was there with you? What helped to support you? Did you have to change? How? Did others have to change? How? What were the consequences of your willingness to risk?
What risks has your current congregation taken or is it taking now? How does it feel to be a part of a group that is willing to risk its identity or its ministry in new and challenging ways? What helps to support the group? Who has to change?
5. Tell us something new
Every congregation is in a constant process of change as it adapts to the culture around it, although some congregations adapt more easily than others.
In what ways is your congregation noticeably different than it was 10-20 years ago? How has it adapted to being a larger or smaller congregation? How has communication to members changed? How has worship changed? What do you do differently than you did 10-20 years ago?
6. Wishes for the Presbytery
The world is changing around us, both as individuals and as the church. What we needed 25 years ago, five years ago, five months ago, is different than what we need today.
Knowing everything that you know—about your family, about your work, about your world, about yourself—what are the three most important things a Presbytery (a group of Presbyterian congregations working together) needs to do in order to be faithful to God in this place and time?